For many employees, the word "assessment" brings to mind a tense moment when they expect criticism. For many managers, it is an administrative chore to get out of the way at the end of the year. In both cases, the exercise loses all its value.
When done well, however, assessment is a powerful tool. It clarifies expectations, recognises the work done, identifies training needs and prepares decisions on career development or pay. But it has to be prepared and based on clear foundations.
Setting clear objectives in advance
You can only assess properly what has been defined in advance. At the start of the period, every employee should know their main duties and the results expected. These objectives must be precise, realistic and verifiable.
"Improve customer service" is too vague. "Respond to every customer complaint within the day and keep a complaints log" is much clearer. For a field sales representative in the West, you might set a number of new sales outlets to open or a sales volume to reach, defined according to the reality of the local market.
Assessing throughout the year
The annual review should not be the only opportunity to talk about the work. Regular check-ins, monthly or quarterly depending on your organisation, let you quickly correct what is not working and praise what is going well. That way, the annual review holds no surprises: it sums up conversations that have already taken place.
Keep a simple record for each team member: notable achievements, difficulties encountered, feedback from customers or colleagues. These notes will stop you from judging the whole year on the last few weeks, a very common bias.
Preparing and conducting the annual review
Notify the employee in advance and suggest they prepare for the conversation, for example using a short self-assessment form. Set aside a quiet time, without interruptions, in a place where confidentiality is ensured.
- Review the past period, objective by objective, letting the employee speak first.
- Discuss the skills used, technical and behavioural, with concrete examples.
- Identify the difficulties encountered and their causes, including those related to the organisation.
- Set the objectives for the next period together.
- Discuss training needs and wishes for career development.
- Write a report signed by both parties.
Listen at least as much as you talk. The employee often knows the practical obstacles of their position better than you do: an unsuitable tool, an overly cumbersome procedure, a lack of information between departments. These comments are valuable for improving the organisation.
Avoiding common pitfalls
- Judging on a general impression rather than on the objectives set.
- Giving everyone the same average rating to avoid conflict.
- Comparing employees with each other in public.
- Promising a pay rise or a promotion you cannot guarantee.
- Forgetting to follow through on commitments made, particularly regarding training.
A fair assessment also requires the criteria to be the same for all employees in comparable positions. Explain clearly how the assessment does or does not affect bonuses and career progression.
Follow-up after the review
A review with no follow-up discourages more than it motivates. In the weeks that follow, go back to the report and check that the commitments made are progressing: enrolment in a training course, a new tool, an adjustment to a task. If a commitment cannot be kept, explain the reason to the employee. This consistency between words and actions is what gives the whole assessment process its credibility.
Assessing your teams shows them that their work matters and that you care about their progress. Set clear objectives, talk regularly, prepare reviews seriously and keep your commitments. Your team members will gain in motivation, and your company in effectiveness.