Estuaire Service
Contact us

HomeBlogJobs and careers

Conducting a structured recruitment interview to choose better

The same questions for everyone, an assessment grid, notes taken on the spot: the method for comparing candidates on objective grounds.

Jobs and careers3 min readFor companies

Many recruitment interviews look like a free conversation. The recruiter asks whatever questions come to mind, relies on intuition and picks the candidate who made the best impression. The risk is real: choosing the person who speaks most comfortably rather than the most competent, or the one who is most like us.

The structured interview offers a different approach. All candidates answer the same questions, assessed against the same criteria. The decision is then based on comparable elements, not on a general impression.

Preparing the interview in advance

Preparation starts with the job description. Identify four to six key skills, technical and behavioural, that will lead to success in the position. For a cashier, for example: accuracy in handling money, welcoming customers, honesty, calm at peak times.

For each skill, write one or two questions. Focus on three types of questions.

  • Questions about past experience: "Tell me about a situation where you noticed a cash discrepancy. What did you do?"
  • Scenario questions: "A customer disputes the change you gave and gets angry in front of the queue. How do you react?"
  • Technical questions suited to the position, possibly accompanied by a short practical exercise.

Avoid questions that are too general, such as "What are your strengths?", which produce ready-made answers. Also avoid questions unrelated to the position or about private life, religion or family plans.

Building an assessment grid

For each question, define in advance what a weak, average or strong answer looks like. A simple scale, from one to four for example, is enough. What matters is that every assessor applies it in the same way.

This grid forces you to clarify your expectations before meeting the candidates. It also limits the halo effect, the bias of judging an entire profile on the basis of a single striking element, such as impeccable clothing or a prestigious school.

How the interview unfolds

  1. Welcome the candidate, introduce yourself and explain how the interview will proceed.
  2. Briefly present the company and the position.
  3. Ask the prepared questions, in the same order for each candidate.
  4. Follow up to get details: what exactly did you do, what was the result?
  5. Leave time for the candidate's questions.
  6. Explain the next steps in the process and when they will hear back.

Take notes during the interview, using the candidate's own words. Fill in the grid immediately afterwards, while your memories are precise. If several people take part, each one assesses separately before comparing.

Adapting the length and setting

Plan the same length of time for all candidates and a quiet place, with no interruptions or phone calls. For an initial screening, a phone or video call may be enough, as long as you use the same set of questions. For practical positions, such as sales, cashier work or maintenance, add a short real-life exercise to the interview: serving a mock customer, writing a message, fixing a simple fault.

Deciding and giving feedback

Compare the completed grids, skill by skill. Discuss differences between assessors using the notes taken. Then check the references of the selected candidate with their former employers, with their consent. Ask factual questions: what were their duties, how did they work in a team, would you hire them again?

Inform all the candidates you met of the decision. A short, respectful message protects your company's image. A candidate who is not selected today may become a customer, a partner or the right profile for a future position.

A structured interview requires a little more preparation at the outset, but it saves time and reduces recruitment mistakes. For an SME, where every hire counts, it is a simple tool for choosing more accurately and more fairly.

Need a hand with recruitment or HR?

Estuaire Service handles recruitment, payroll, digital and training for companies in Cameroon.

Talk to our team